UPDATE: Here is video of the lesson in question.
Reflections on Teaching for Week 4: Choral Repetition in
large classes
I’m trying to adjust my teaching style to better suit a 35
student middle-school class after teaching small (4-12 student) university
classes for the past few years. It’s a challenge and one of the things I’m
noticing is I have to apply different methods than I would in an intimate adult
EFL classroom where I can engage more easily one-on-one with the students. It’s
kind of like reprogramming yourself and examining, sometimes reluctantly, which
of your teaching techniques are still effective and which should be scaled back
or discarded. One technique I find myself employing more these days is choral repetition. Since it’s a public
school with standardized exams, I have to prepare the students to remember and
become familiar with new vocabulary. I
show them a PPT of different terms and then we repeat the name and definition. I
try individual repetition and dialogic exchanges when I can, but with
such large classes I find myself relying on choral repetition and monologic or more specifically the
dreaded (at least for me) closed display
questions to keep the pace of the class flowing uninterrupted. I’ve found
with middle-school students, if some students are neglected while you engage
with others, they can easily lose focus and that’s when you’re at risk of
losing control of the class.
The problem
is I question how challenging or
impactful such an approach is, even with basic EFL learners. There is no room
for critical thinking when you are teaching a lesson based around memorizing
terms for a test. This kind of “teaching
for the test” goes against my personal
teaching philosophy (I would prefer much heavier interaction and to see
practical application of the terms in their own sentences), but the school
requires it to be taught in this method. I tried to insert dialogic questions
when I could, but they were more open questions to the entire class than
targeted towards individual students. I’m trying to reassess at this point what
I can do to become happier with this new class dynamic. I’ve considered
grouping the students and giving them hand-outs based on the terms, so they can
engage in student-to-student interaction
and have dialogic discourse with each other, but when I’ve tried this in other
classes I’ve noticed their conversation rarely stays on topic and as previously
mentioned there’s the loss of classroom control to take into account.
I think an additional hurdle to take into
account is that they’re used to the more traditional Korean approach of
monologic discourse and choral repetition, so to introduce and have them adapt
to a new style of learning is something that might prove difficult, since they
could misinterpret a more open and casual classroom environment as an excuse
for chaos and disengagement. After the Chuseok break, I will seriously evaluate
my approach and search for a way I can keep my students focused while teaching
the way I’d prefer to teach. The first thing I might try is ditching the very
dry, boilerplate PPTs the school provides me with, and make my own that will
have questions focusing on personalization
(such as for ‘tooth’, talk about how you lost your last tooth with a
partner) that will open up more avenues for discussion. I might couple that
with handouts and if I do divide them up into pairs or groups I might create a
point system to keep their attention focused.
At the moment, it's unclear exactly what method is required by your employer. I was about to say that your talents are wasted where you are, and that you could simply find a new employer at your next opportunity. But if you can ditch the ppts, personalize (too complex a question about losing a tooth without some prep?) even with something silly like "find your biggest tooth and show it to your partner"...
ReplyDeleteThanks, Tom. The biggest mistake I made was leaving my university job where I had a lot more autonomy. Hell, I had more autonomy at my first hagwon job. I've been in a funk with this job, because I feel I might as well be a robot half the time. They have units in their textbook they want me to teach and it's hard to stray too much from it. I've decided I am going to give notice. I have to give 60 days notice per their guidelines and that won't be too fun. It also would be the first job in my 6 years in Korea that I didn't complete my whole contract for, which could hurt my resume. I might freelance again and do privates, because I found that much more rewarding. If Michael and Swati can do that, so can I. Thanks for the comment.
Delete